The Mentoring Desk · Edition 001
A Broken Download Link. A Life-Changing Mentor. A Question We Should All Be Asking.
What an unexpected mentoring relationship taught me about access, opportunity, and why we need to be more intentional about connecting people.
In 2013, nine months after arriving in Canada, I purchased a few job aids and two ebooks on business analysis from an online store in the United States.
The download links didn't work.
After waiting almost the entire day, I emailed customer support.
That evening, my phone rang.
An American number.
The person on the other end apologized, fixed the problem, and followed up by email.
Nothing particularly extraordinary, except for two things.
It was a Sunday evening.
And the person who called wasn't a customer support representative.
She was the author herself.
Her name was Roxanne Miller.
I was stunned.
Here was an accomplished professional taking time on a Sunday evening to resolve a problem with a customer's order. But what stayed with me wasn't simply the customer service.
It was how she treated me.
We exchanged emails. She offered encouragement, answered questions, and even sent me additional learning materials I hadn't requested.
At the time, I was still trying to find my professional footing in Canada. I had arrived with education and experience, but translating those assets into opportunities in a new country was proving difficult. I was not getting interviews. No one was willing to talk to me because my training and work experience were from outside North America. I lacked the so-called "Canadian experience" in my field of expertise. To pay the bills and support my family, I worked three minimum-wage jobs: one at night, one during the day and the third in the evenings.
Roxanne was one of the first people I encountered professionally who seemed genuinely interested in what I could become.
She saw a professional at a time when my circumstances were making me question whether I still was one.
Six days after our first conversation, I sent her an email asking if she would consider becoming my mentor.
I told her we hardly knew each other, but I hoped she might give me a chance.
Then I wrote:
"You are a giant gone ahead of me and I will like to sit on your shoulders...if you will let me."
And because apparently I couldn't resist a joke, I added:
"And by the way, I am not heavy so I shouldn't hurt your shoulders ;)"
She said yes.
She gave me more than professional advice
One of our earliest exchanges remains particularly memorable.
When Roxanne asked me to tell her about myself, I suggested she look at my LinkedIn profile.
Her response?
"How about telling me some things about yourself that I can't read on LinkedIn?"
That question changed the nature of our interaction.
She wasn't simply interested in my qualifications. She wanted to know the person behind them.
Over the following years, she helped develop my skills in business analysis, challenged my thinking, answered questions, and introduced me to other experienced professionals, including Karl Wiegers, whose work became influential in my career.
Three years after our first interaction, I approached her about using her training materials to establish a business analysis training practice in Calgary.
She agreed, provided I attended her training in person and we formalized the arrangement.
Then she waived my training fee.
And paid for four nights of hotel accommodation.
We had never met face-to-face.
When I expressed my astonishment and gratitude, she replied:
"I'm simply paying forward blessings that were bestowed upon me. ;)"
Later, when she had more consulting opportunities than she could handle, she referred clients to me.
She was willing to put her own professional reputation behind me.
Our relationship eventually developed into a business partnership and, over time, a lasting friendship.
Looking back, I can identify several things Roxanne gave me: knowledge, encouragement, honest feedback, professional access, and opportunities.
Perhaps the most consequential thing she gave me was the confidence to see possibilities beyond my immediate circumstances.
What research tells us about mentoring
My experience was deeply personal, but it also illustrates something mentoring research has described for decades.
In her foundational work, Mentoring at Work (1985), Kathy Kram identified two major functions of mentoring.
The first is career development: helping people acquire skills, gain exposure, navigate opportunities, and advance professionally.
The second is psychosocial development: supporting confidence, professional identity, acceptance, and personal growth.
Roxanne provided both.
She helped me become more competent. And when she asked what she couldn't read on LinkedIn, she was doing what Kram called acceptance and confirmation: taking me seriously as a professional, and as a person. That helped me regain confidence in my professional identity. Kram counted friendship among these functions too, and ours has lasted.
And when she began referring clients to me, she was acting as a sponsor. In Kram's framework, sponsorship is one of the career functions: actively using your influence to open doors for someone.
Later writers have drawn a sharper line between the two roles. A mentor helps you prepare for an opportunity. A sponsor puts their reputation behind you to help create access to that opportunity.
These functions can coexist within a mentoring relationship, but they are not interchangeable.
A 2019 synthesis by the U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine puts relationship quality at the centre: trust, clear expectations, appropriate boundaries, and mutual commitment.
Simply connecting two people does not guarantee a meaningful mentoring relationship.
That distinction should concern anyone responsible for running a mentoring program.
The question that stayed with me
I often reflect on how Roxanne and I met.
I purchased some books.
The download links failed.
I emailed customer support.
She called.
We connected.
And my professional journey took a different direction.
I am profoundly grateful for that sequence of events.
But it also raises an uncomfortable question.
Why should someone's opportunity to find a life-changing mentor depend on a broken download link?
What happens to the capable newcomer who never encounters someone like Roxanne?
Or the young professional whose family has no established professional networks?
Or the entrepreneur who needs guidance but doesn't know where to find it?
Or the talented employee whose potential remains largely invisible within an organization?
Of course, not every mentoring relationship will transform a life. And mentoring alone cannot eliminate structural barriers to opportunity.
But if we believe developmental relationships can help people acquire knowledge, navigate unfamiliar systems, and access opportunities, shouldn't we be more intentional about making those relationships available?
This is one of the questions that eventually led me to found Mentorfy, a platform designed to help organizations launch, manage, and evaluate mentoring programs.
It also informs my doctoral research into mentoring relationships, including what makes mentor–mentee matches work, how expectations become misaligned, and what organizations can do to support better experiences.
I have come to believe that access to meaningful mentoring should not depend entirely on privilege, proximity, or chance.
But creating that access takes more than putting names into a matching system.
It requires us to think seriously about the relationship itself.
At Your Mentoring Desk
If your organization currently operates a mentoring program, consider these three questions:
1. Are we measuring connections or development?
Knowing that 100 people were matched tells us something about program activity. It tells us considerably less about whether participants learned, developed, or gained meaningful opportunities.
2. What happens after the match?
Do participants understand their expectations, responsibilities, and boundaries? Are they prepared for the relationship? Is support available when things don't go as expected?
3. Who might be missing out?
Are the people who most need developmental relationships able to access your program? Or do participation requirements, recruitment practices, and existing networks inadvertently favour those who are already well connected?
These questions don't provide a complete program evaluation.
But they are a useful place to begin.
Why I'm starting The Mentoring Desk
I've spent years reflecting on what Roxanne's investment meant to my life, and trying to extend that same generosity of knowledge and opportunity to others.
That's why I'm launching The Mentoring Desk.
Sometimes I'll share personal experiences. Other times, we'll examine research findings, program practices, cultural perspectives, and questions submitted by readers.
I'll distinguish what the evidence establishes from what I believe or have observed in practice.
Because good intentions are not enough.
If mentoring matters, then how we design, deliver, and evaluate it should matter just as much.
The conversation continues
I'd like to end this inaugural edition with a question.
If you're involved in running, leading, or funding a mentoring program, what is the one challenge you wish someone could help you think through?
It could be matching, mentor recruitment, participant engagement, relationship quality, measuring outcomes, securing funding, or something entirely different.
I'd genuinely like to hear about it.
Your questions and experiences will help shape future editions of The Mentoring Desk.
I don't claim to have every answer. But I believe the questions are worth examining together, thoughtfully and with evidence.
After all, one of the most consequential relationships in my life began with a question.
And someone who was willing to answer.
Research note: Kram, K. E. (1985). Mentoring at Work: Developmental Relationships in Organizational Life. Scott, Foresman. For a contemporary research synthesis, see National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (2019), The Science of Effective Mentorship in STEMM: https://doi.org/10.17226/25568 (opens in a new tab)
First published on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)
Reading this on the web? Send me your answer at dapo at mentorfy dot ca.
Get The Mentoring Desk
A free newsletter on running mentoring programs that work, every two weeks. Issues are in English for now.
All fields are required unless marked optional.
Almost there. Please check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.
